Gary Naysmith vs James Michael Goodwin: the coaches side by side

Filter:
Gary Naysmith Scotland ยท 47 years old Stenhousemuir
vs
James Michael Goodwin Republic of Ireland ยท 44 years old Dundee Utd
98 - 169 Matches
30% - 40% Win percentage
1.13 - 1.47 Points per match
1.32 - 1.43 Goals scored per match

Every match we track for both coaches, since the 2017 season. We have no matches of Gary Naysmith from the 2020 season.

Records side by side

Gary Naysmith James Michael Goodwin
Results
98 Matches 169
29 Won 68
24 Draw 45
45 Lost 56
30% Win percentage 40%
46% Loss percentage 33%
1.13 Points per match 1.47
Goals
1.32 Goals scored per match 1.43
1.58 Goals conceded per match 1.20
-0.27 Goal difference per match 0.23
24% Clean sheets (%) 34%
33% Failed to score (%) 24%
51% Both teams scored 48%
58% Over 2.5 goals 48%
Home and away
1.20 Points per home match 1.56
1.06 Points per away match 1.39
30% Home wins (%) 46%
29% Away wins (%) 34%
Runs
6 Longest winning run 4
6 Longest unbeaten run 17

Gary Naysmith against James Michael Goodwin

0 Wins
1 Draw
4 Wins

The teams of Gary Naysmith and James Michael Goodwin met 5 times: 0 wins for Gary Naysmith, 1 draws and 4 wins for James Michael Goodwin. The team of Gary Naysmith scored 4 goals, the team of James Michael Goodwin 11.

Every meeting between Stenhousemuir and Dundee Utd ยท Every meeting between Queen of the South and Alloa Athletic

Per club

Gary Naysmith
Clubs M W-D-L PPG
Queen of the South2017 - 2018 77 24-23-30 1.23
Stenhousemuir2022 - 2025 15 3-0-12 0.60
Edinburgh City2021 6 2-1-3 1.17
James Michael Goodwin
Clubs M W-D-L PPG
Dundee Utd2022 - 2026 101 44-27-30 1.57
Alloa Athletic2017 - 2018 41 11-10-20 1.05
ST Mirren2019 - 2021 25 13-8-4 1.88
Aberdeen2022 2 0-0-2 0.00

In the same competitions

Competition Gary Naysmith James Michael Goodwin
M W% PPG M W% PPG
Scottish Championship 70 29% 1.14 68 44% 1.59
Scottish League Cup 22 32% 1.14 32 47% 1.59
Scottish FA Cup 6 33% 1.00 13 38% 1.46

Season by season

Season Gary Naysmith James Michael Goodwin
Clubs M W% PPG Clubs M W% PPG
2026 - - - Dundee Utd 1 0% 1.00
2025 Stenhousemuir 2 50% 1.50 Dundee Utd 14 21% 1.21
2024 Stenhousemuir 7 14% 0.43 Dundee Utd 44 41% 1.41
2023 Stenhousemuir 5 20% 0.60 Dundee Utd 38 61% 2.08
2022 Stenhousemuir 1 0% 0.00 Dundee Utd Aberdeen 6 0% 0.00
2021 Edinburgh City 6 33% 1.17 ST Mirren 6 83% 2.67
2020 - - - ST Mirren 11 55% 1.91
2019 - - - ST Mirren 8 25% 1.25
2018 Queen of the South 38 26% 1.05 Alloa Athletic 38 29% 1.13
2017 Queen of the South 39 36% 1.41 Alloa Athletic 3 0% 0.00

Gary Naysmith vs James Michael Goodwin in numbers

Since the 2017 season Gary Naysmith led 98 matches we track: 29 wins, 24 draws and 45 losses, good for 1.13 points per match. Since the 2017 season James Michael Goodwin led 169 matches we track: 68 wins, 45 draws and 56 losses, good for 1.47 points per match.

More on both coaches: all about Gary Naysmith, all about James Michael Goodwin, compare other coaches.